The Intersecting Crises of Domestic Assault Charges: Family and Criminal Law

This post may contain affiliate links. Read the full disclosure here.

Traveling, commuting, or relocating to Ontario, Canada?

In Ontario, being charged with domestic assault (a crime under section 265 of the Criminal Code of Canada) starts an immediate and serious legal crisis that affects both criminal law and family law. For people who are accused, the effects go far beyond fines and possible jail time. They immediately put parental rights, access to property, and, most importantly, contact with their own children at risk. To get through this intersection safely, you need a specialized legal defense that knows how serious both jurisdictions are.

The Immediate Effect: Conditions of Criminal Bail

In Ontario, when someone is charged with domestic assault, the police and the Crown Attorney’s office usually follow a strict “zero-tolerance” policy. This means that the accused is almost always held for a bail hearing after they are arrested.

The main goal of the bail hearing is to keep the complainant and the public safe. Because of this, the Justice of the Peace will almost certainly set strict rules against contact. These conditions make it illegal for the accused to talk to the complainant directly or indirectly, and they often also make it illegal for the accused to live at the family home or even be near it. These conditions often apply to children, which means that the accused may not be able to see their children, even if there are already custody agreements in place.

This immediate and enforced separation, although a procedural requirement in the criminal justice system, results in an immediate void in the realm of family law.

Parallel Proceedings: Effects on Family Law

A criminal charge has serious effects on the family court at the same time. The assault charge and the non-contact order that goes with it are very important to any family law case that comes after, like a divorce, separation, or custody and access dispute.

The court’s only guiding principle in custody and access cases is what is best for the child. When deciding what is best for the child, courts must take into account any evidence of family violence. Even if the parent is not found guilty, the criminal charge and the police evidence that goes along with it can make it very hard for them to get or keep access. The complainant may also ask for a civil Restraining Order under the Family Law Act. This can make the conditions of the criminal bail order more official and last longer.

The crisis has two sides, so winning in criminal court can greatly reduce harm in family court, and vice versa. One mistake in one case can be used as strong proof in the other.

The Importance of Specialized Legal Help

The complicated relationship between these two legal systems shows how important it is to hire highly skilled and specialized defense lawyers right away. When you’re facing charges that could put your freedom and family ties at risk, it’s not just a good idea to hire the best domestic assault lawyer in Ontario; it’s necessary.

To be a good lawyer in this area, you need to know two things. They need to know a lot about criminal procedure to handle the bail process, talk to the Crown, and get ready for trial. At the same time, they need to know about family law so they can advise on custody issues, handle communication with family counsel, and make sure that their criminal strategy doesn’t hurt the client’s case in family court.

The choice of lawyer made in the first 48 hours after a domestic assault charge will affect the whole course of the criminal case and the preservation of family ties. Because there are mandatory minimum sentences for domestic violence convictions and the effects on custody and access rights are permanent, the only way to protect yourself from these threats is to hire a lawyer who knows everything about them.

*This article is based on personal suggestions and/or experiences and is for informational purposes only. This should not be used as professional advice. Please consult a professional where applicable.