While Most States Saw Job Losses Rise, Michigan Saw Them Fall
Photo by Ralf Ruppert
Article courtesy of DOKKA.
- Nevada leads all states with a 74.9% rise in businesses cutting jobs since 2000, from 13,726 a year to 24,013, equivalent to an extra 327 job cuts per 100,000 residents.
- Idaho and Utah follow closely at 67.9% and 67.4% increases in businesses cutting jobs, respectively.
- 47 states have seen an increase in job losses rather than a reduction.
- Michigan, Ohio and West Virginia are the three states that have actually seen a reduction in job losses since 2000.
New research reveals which states have seen the biggest increase in businesses cutting jobs since 2000, with only three states actually seeing a reduction in the number of job losses since 2000.
The study, conducted by DOKKA, an accounting automation software company, tracked the number of private sector establishments losing jobs from the BLS Business Employment Dynamics report. These figures were then cross-referenced by the population to standardize the data.
Nationally, job losses rose from 1,839,057 in 2000 to 2,248,780 in 2024, a 22.3% increase. On a per-capita basis, this looks like 550 to 673 per 100,000 residents, which is an increase of 123 per 100,000 over 24 years.
The states with the largest increase in businesses cutting jobs
| Rank | State | Raw losses (2000) | Raw losses (2024) | Raw difference | Percentage change | Per 100,000 residents (2000) | Per 100,000 residents (2024) | Per 100,000 change |
| 1 | Nevada | 13,726 | 24,013 | +10,287 | +74.9% | 437 | 764 | +327 |
| 2 | Idaho | 10,927 | 18,350 | +7,423 | +67.9% | 564 | 946 | +383 |
| 3 | Utah | 16,711 | 27,978 | +11,267 | +67.4% | 489 | 819 | +330 |
| 4 | Florida | 99,230 | 161,147 | +61,917 | +62.4% | 439 | 713 | +274 |
| 5 | Arizona | 28,696 | 43,426 | +14,730 | +51.3% | 386 | 584 | +198 |
| 6 | Texas | 118,695 | 174,768 | +56,073 | +47.2% | 389 | 573 | +184 |
| 7 | Tennessee | 32,583 | 46,690 | +14,107 | +43.3% | 472 | 676 | +204 |
| 8 | North Dakota | 5,447 | 7,624 | +2,177 | +40.0% | 699 | 979 | +279 |
| 9 | Montana | 8,423 | 11,698 | +3,275 | +38.9% | 751 | 1,043 | +292 |
| 10 | Colorado | 36,291 | 50,058 | +13,767 | +37.9% | 622 | 857 | +236 |
Nevada leads the study with a 74.9% rise in job losses since 2000, climbing from 13,726 per year to 24,013 per year which is an increase of 10,287 in raw terms. When looking per capita, the rate rose from 437 to 764 per 100,000 residents, an increase of 327.
Idaho ranks second with 67.9% more job losses in 2024 compared to 2000, rising from 10,927 to 18,350 in raw terms which is an increase of 7,423. The per-capita rise of 383 per 100,000 residents (from 564 to 946) is the largest of any state.
Utah places third with a 67.4% increase, from 16,711 job losses in 2000 to 27,978 in 2024. Per capita, the rate rose 330 per 100,000 people, from 489 to 819.
Florida ranks fourth with a 62.4% increase while Arizona ranks fifth with an increase of 51.3% of job losses. For Florida, this is an increase of 61,917 businesses cutting jobs per year while in Arizona this figure stands at 14,730 compared to 2000.
In sixth is Texas where there are 47.2% more job losses per year compared to 2000. Looking at the raw numbers this is the second largest increase of any state after Florida. Per capita, the rise stands at 184 per 100,000.
With a 43.3% increase in job losses from 2000 is Tennessee, which ranks seventh. In 2000, there were 32,583 businesses cutting jobs per year compared to 46,690 now in 2024 which is an additional 14,107.
North Dakota has a 40% increase in job losses, from 5,447 per year in 2000 to 7,624 per year in 2024, causing the state to have the eighth highest rate. On a per-capita basis, the state has a rise of 279 per 100,000 (from 699 to 979).
Montana places ninth at an increase of 38.9% and Colorado rounds out the top 10 with an increase of 37.9%.
The states with the smallest increase in job losses (or rise)
| Rank | State | Raw losses (2000) | Raw losses (2024) | Raw difference | Percentage
change |
Per 100,000 residents (2000) | Per 100,000 residents (2024) | Per 100,000 change |
| 1 | Michigan | 59,359 | 57,188 | -2,171 | -3.7% | 591 | 570 | -22 |
| 2 | Ohio | 72,296 | 70,802 | -1,494 | -2.1% | 613 | 600 | -13 |
| 3 | West Virginia | 11,297 | 11,100 | -197 | -1.7% | 638 | 627 | -11 |
| 4 | Washington | 50,456 | 51,395 | +939 | +1.9% | 648 | 660 | +12 |
| 5 | Iowa | 22,742 | 23,240 | +498 | +2.2% | 709 | 725 | +16 |
| 6 | Illinois | 73,458 | 75,220 | +1,762 | +2.4% | 584 | 598 | +14 |
| 7 | Louisiana | 27,370 | 28,118 | +748 | +2.7% | 599 | 615 | +16 |
| 8 | Kansas | 19,436 | 20,341 | +905 | +4.7% | 662 | 693 | +31 |
| 9 | Indiana | 39,184 | 41,016 | +1,832 | +4.7% | 573 | 600 | +27 |
| 10 | New York | 124,888 | 131,324 | +6,436 | +5.2% | 618 | 650 | +32 |
Michigan is the state to record the largest fall in private establishments cutting jobs since 2000, down 3.7% from 59,359 in 2000 to 57,188 in 2024. The per-capita rate fell 22 per 100,000, from 591 to 570.
This is followed by Ohio which ranks second at -2.1% in job losses. In 2000, there were 72,296 job losses per year, compared to 70,802 in 2024.
West Virginia places third and is the last state in the country to record a decline in job losses. West Virginia has seen job losses fall by 1.7%, from 11,297 job losses in 2000 to 11,100 in 2024.
Commenting on the findings, Eric Edelstein, Co-founder at DOKKA said: “This study reveals a trend for the current job market. You’d assume that in the past couple of decades and with the advances of technology, that job availability would increase when in fact, according to this study, it’s the opposite. For the vast majority of America, job losses are on the rise with only a lucky few states seeing a reduction in job losses, and even these aren’t as high as you’d hope it would be. It’s worth adding that rapid growth naturally brings more business churn, meaning more businesses opening and more businesses contracting or closing
Business owners that are worried about financial stability, particularly in the states that rank highly, should consider their expenses on a more frequent basis. Now that there is so much variety in softwares and tech with rapidly increasing advancements, business owners and finance teams in companies need to be constantly sourcing the right tools and making sure the tools themselves can keep up with business requirements.
The study was compiled by DOKKA, one team that’s united under one goal which is to revolutionize how finance teams work. They are doing that with proprietary technology that eliminates the need for manual work in all accounting functions, from bookkeeping to controlling.
About the expert:
Eric is a Co-Founder at DOKKA.com, a SAAS platform for Finance Teams to Augment their ERPs With a Next-Gen Accounting Automation Platform. Previously, Eric co-founded global search marketing agency Clicks2Customers as well as the incuBeta group. The group was purchased by NMPi, and currently has over 800 employees in 19 countries. Eric is a partner in Global Sunset Investments, which invests in early stage startup’s in the USA, UK, South Africa, and Israel. The portfolio currently includes Guardz Cyber, Sotero, Majestic, & Civic. Exits include Quirk, Yola & BrandsEye.
Sources:
Dokka.com
Bureau of Labor Statistics, Business Employment Dynamics – Number of private sector establishments by direction of employment change, seasonally adjusted.
Methodology:
Establishment data was sourced from the BLS Business Employment Dynamics programme, Table 5, which reports the number of private sector establishments gaining and losing jobs each quarter on a seasonally adjusted basis. Annual averages were calculated from quarterly figures for each state. The year 2000 annual average is used as the baseline. Per-capita figures are calculated using estimated 2024 state resident populations and expressed per 100,000 residents. ‘Establishments shedding jobs’ includes both contracting establishments (reducing headcount) and closing establishments.

